Talk:An Under-Edd's-Hat Theory/@comment-98.114.141.54-20130504041210

Ok, time to call bullhonkey on that dodgeball theory... if Edd was a toddler/baby when he moved to Peach Creek and already was wearing the hat, it makes no sense for him to have started wearing the hat after an incident in an Elementary school in another town. Huh??

Also, I've played dodgeball and the balls aren't even remotely hard enough to visibly deform someones head permanately, that's just crazy. Also given EEnE's logic, characters have recieved far more dramatic injuries that would normally kill a person and recovered just fine.

Finally, I highly doubt Edd was EVER athletic in any sort of way... he is just naturally very weak and unathletic, as literally all of his interests revolve around doing unathletic things and he doesn't have a dominating, competitive personality or any drive to hurt other people. The only thing about  dodge ball he might be good at, or maybe at least became good at since the incident, is dodging things- neurotic people tend to be very jumpy and flinchy and if he has developed a natural fear of being hit by something, he could have developed excellent evasiv skills (as demonstrated in the water balloon scene... though it doesn't take a genius to figure out where to move to in order to avoid an incoming obstacle if given enough time to move)